Peter Prentiss – Your Trusted Real Estate Professional

Known for his easygoing, patient, and upbeat demeanor, he is a favorite among buyers, sellers, and fellow agents alike. His high responsiveness and genuine aloha spirit, combined with a warm, welcoming, and optimistic personality, set him apart.

Born and raised on Hawai'i Island, Peter graduated from Hawai’i Preparatory Academy in 2005 before pursuing Marine Science and Environmental Studies at the University of San Diego. Graduating in 2009, he developed a passion for sustainability and returned home to work in the research and cultivation of algae and other marine organisms. He later became an educator, teaching students of all ages from Pahoa to Kohala, which refined his skills as a clear and effective communicator.

Now raising his family on the Hamakua Coast, Peter has lived in almost every corner of Hawai'i Island, cultivating a deep appreciation for its natural beauty and diverse communities. His extensive knowledge of the island’s culture, school districts, agricultural potential, microclimates, and real estate market makes him uniquely qualified to assist clients in finding their perfect home.

Having built an off-grid homestead in Hawaiian Paradise Park and renovated numerous homes as a professional handyman, Peter’s comprehensive understanding of construction, buying, and selling is further enriched by his upbringing by two seasoned real estate brokers and home builders. With profound local knowledge and strong negotiating skills, Peter is dedicated to making your dreams of staying in Hawaii or finding a new home on the island a reality.

Dylan Nonaka

Broker in Charge

808.937.8382

dylan@buybigisland.com

Cindy Hornbacher

Transaction Coordinator

808.443.4200

cinydhornbacher.tc@gmail.com

Meet The Team

Working with our team means gaining access to a wealth of local expertise, innovative strategies, and a network of resources that span the entire state. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, our agents are committed to understanding your unique needs and providing personalized solutions tailored to your goals.

From the lush landscapes of Kauai to the vibrant communities of Oahu and the stunning shores of Maui and the Big Island, we offer comprehensive support to clients throughout Hawaii. Our team is here to guide you every step of the way, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable real estate experience.

The Value of working with our Team

I am not just an individual agent working for you—our team of over 100 agents statewide brings all our collective resources and expertise to your service.

As part of a statewide operation, we can show you property anywhere in the state within 4 hours, guided by a local market expert. Last year, we helped over 600 families buy or sell real estate, and we are here to assist you with the same dedication.

If you require specialized advice, our team includes experts in various real estate fields:

First-Time Home Buyers
Luxury Certified Agents
Short-Term Vacation Rentals
Farm and Ranch Properties
Vacant Land
Off-the-Grid Living
Second and Vacation Homes
Foreclosure, Short Sale, and Distressed Properties
New Construction
Long-Term Rental Investments
Leasehold Properties
Investor/ Fix and Flip
VA Loans
And more!

Our team includes six highly experienced brokers available 12 hours a day to support us if any issues arise during your transaction. Our brokerage is #1 in Hawaii for the number of properties sold in the past 12 months. Thanks to our size, we have access to more off-market listings than anyone else through our exclusive internal listing service, eXp Exclusives.

We're proud to be an exclusive partner with Zillow and have earned over 500 five-star reviews!

To further assist you, we will provide an Island-specific Home Buyer guide, offering in-depth information about the island and important considerations when purchasing property.

Our list of team-vetted vendors, including home inspectors, surveyors, termite companies, handymen, contractors, landscapers, movers, attorneys, and more, will ensure you have all the support you need during and after the transaction.

We will keep you informed with weekly real estate updates and monthly market reports before and after your transaction.

Our experienced transaction coordinators will oversee the escrow process to ensure everything runs smoothly and all contractual timelines are met.

Lastly, you'll have access to our lending partners at NFM Lending and their exclusive programs for our clients. This includes an $808 lender credit at closing for qualified buyers, a free refinance within 5 years, and a no-risk appraisal fee if your transaction does not close.